Well, I find it very interesting that we may be on our way to understanding depression from a different perspective – especially for those who have been on antidepressants and have not found lasting effective treatment. This new knowledge has led to a natural vitamin treatment without side effects!
GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT THE GENETIC TEST
The genetic test – which can be done from a simple blood draw- is called the MTHFR test. The official name of this gene is “5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase” (NADPH). MTHFR is the gene’s official shorthand symbol – and now you know why! Just for an interesting clarification, the gene is located on the short (p) arm of chromosome 1 at position 36.3.
The normal function of this gene provides instructions for making an enzyme called methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase. This hormone plays a key role in processing amino acids, the building blocks of proteins. If a mutation occurs in the MTHFR gene, folate/B vitamins may not be broken down in such a way that the body can utilize them.
(Let it be known that this research and information is very difficult to understand and translate; in fact, it is nearly indecipherable to this lay person! I have struggled with it and the following is hard won information which I hope will help you to understand this complex and emerging field.)
From a review of some of the literature and research on the MTHFR genetic abnormality, mutations of this gene may be implicated with the following:
- elevated homocystiene levels (a potentially toxic amino acid) leading to heart problems
- venous thrombosis
- blood clotting issues
- certain types of severe birth defects (for example, neural tube defects)
- miscarriages
- high blood pressure in pregnancy
- coronary heart disease and stroke
- mental illness, most often connected with depression and possibly schizophrenia
Researchers from all over the world are publishing studies searching for additional connections; a lot more information is on the way
Depression
In reference to my focus on mental health, The Hordaland Homocysteine Study is the one most quoted for their research connecting the MTHFR 677C-T mutation with difficulty metabolizing folate and B12; this leads to issues of elevated homocysteine, anxiety and depression. Another important study is entitled: “The Thermolabile variant of the MTHFR is associated with depression in the British Women’s Heart and Health Study and a meta-analysis.”
Both of these studies suggest that due to the body’s inability to metabolize folate/ B- 12 there is a greater risk of depression. Here is how it appears to work:
- Depressive symptoms may be linked to insufficient neurotransmitters or imbalance of one or more of the three neurotransmitters:
- Serotonin (linked to obsessions and compulsions and memory)
- Nor-epinephrine (linked to alertness, concentration and energy)
- Dopamine (linked to pleasure, reward, motivation and drive)
- When these three neurotransmitters are in sufficient quantity and in balance, anxiety is reduced, impulse control and irritability is minimized, there is a capacity for positive mood and good cognitive function, attention can be maintained, and appetite is in normalized. There is also normalized sexual drive and reduced aggression.
- Your doctor or other health care provider may prescribe antidepressants to treat the imbalance of these neurotransmitters. However, what we have come to see is that a significant portion of the population that does not respond successfully to antidepressants.
- This research may point to the reason for ineffective treatment of depression by antidepressants alone. The theory here is that the brain may not be producing enough neurotransmitters due to insufficient amounts of L-methylfolate in the brain. L-methylfolate is needed to regulate serotonin, nor-epinephrine and dopamine production. Without enough L-methylfolate it may be difficult for the brain to produce enough neurotransmitters for the antidepressant to work fully.
- An abnormality in the MTHFR gene prevents the breakdown of folate/B vitamins; as a result, the neurotransmitter building blocks are not available for health brain function. By taking an activated, or metabolized form of folate/B vitamins the body is then able to produce sufficient neurotransmitters . This alone may improve functioning for some; for others, by combining the activated form of folate/B12 with antidepressants, improved results follow.
- 70 percent of those with a diagnosis of depression may have a specific genetic factor that limits their ability to convert folic acid or folate from food or supplements to L-methylfolate.
- The prescription Deplin is actually L-methylfolate in an active, metabolized form that can cross the blood brain barrier to help the brain regulate these important neurotransmitters associated with mood. This is a prescription item only, and is not available in drug or health food stores off the shelf.
- There are no side effects with this product (as reported by the company that produces Deplin); patient surveys have shown 86 percent symptom improvement.
Test results show that if there is a positive genetic mutation it may be what is called homozygous or heterozygous. Here is a more detailed explanation of the definition of these terms. These definitions are taken from http://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com:
- Two copies: Homozygous
- One copy: heterozygous
“having two different alleles at corresponding loci on homologous chromosomes. An individual who is heterozygous for a trait has inherited an allele for that trait from one parent and an alternative allele from the other parent. An individual who is heterozygous for a genetic disease caused by a dominant allele, such as Huntington’s disease, manifests the disorder. A person who is heterozygous for a hereditary disorder produced by a recessive allele, such as sickle cell anemia, is asymptomatic or exhibits reduced symptoms of the disease. The offspring of a heterozygous carrier of a genetic disorder have a 50% chance of inheriting the allele associated with the disorder if the other parent does not carry the allele.”
(While this level of detail is not easily understood, I wanted to insert it here since this is the language that geneticists use in sharing the results of the genetic tests administered.)
What all this complex information means is that it is now possible to effect positive emotional changes by identifying these genetic abnormalities and adding to the treatment regimen an activated (metabolized) B vitamin, thereby aiding in the production of neurotransmitters, which are the basis for health brain function. These are the potential benefits to this protocol:
- motivation
- alertness
- initiative
- concentration
- improved mood
- sociability
This is new information and much more research is needed to understand how the genetic mutations of the MTHFR gene affect us; what is exciting is that the introduction of a natural vitamin may provide the key to improved mental health in over 70% of people with depression.
Does genetics determine our fate? Not necessarily. Some genetic predispositions can be altered by understanding and altering our diet and lifestyle. This is called Epi-Genetics! Above and beyond genetics. Welcome to the new world.
I will keep you posted as I gain more knowledge of this critically important emerging field.
Cynthia
Cynthia, You have simplified this nicely! There is also some evidence that persons with alcoholism or eating disorders could be effected by this mutation and could benefit from Deplin. There is also the possibility that people who had previously needed antidepressants would no longer be required to take them should the Deplin provide enough “support” on its own. Great job!
Candice Chase says: I have been struggling with depression for much of my life. I have found certain antidepressants, exercise, and staying connected with people to be somewhat helpful—however, a low level of depression is often still present.
After learning from you about the possibility that a genetic problem might be related to depression, I had the blood MTHFR blood test and found that I do have a mutation of the gene. Now I am looking forward to finding out what my next steps should be. I don’t really like taking medications if I don’t have to; it would be nothing short of a miracle if taking a certain form of B-vitamins alleviate my depression!
I hope others who write in will share information about doctors they have found helpful, since I’m finding it to be quite a challenge to find one who knows much about this new and exciting information.
Thank you!
P.S.
I finally found out the exact meanings of the words “folate,” “folic acid,” and how they relate to B vitamins, which is helpful when I talk to doctors. “Folic acid” and “folate” are different words for vitamin B-9, which is used by the body to make new cells. Folic acid is the man-made type of vitamin B-9 that is used in vitamin supplements and added to certain foods (called enriched or fortified foods). Folate is the natural type of vitamin B-9 and it is found in green leafy vegetables, citrus fruits, beans, peas and nuts. The biggest difference between folic acid and folate is that folic acid is used more easily by the body than folate. [from http://www.youngwomenshealth.org/folicacid.html
I have a 14 year old son who has been suffering from depression since age 9. Prozac only holds him for a short time. We recently had MTHFR testing for a complete other reason and found that he does in fact have the gene mutation. His psychatrist has recommended Deplin. I spoke with the Peds Hematologist and we are going to go for it. I am so optimistic that this is going to end his suffering. I have an identical twin sister and through genetic testing we learned that 40% of the pop has this mutation, but docs normally get concerned with cardiovascular concerns. Depression is not always tied to the MTHFR gene mutation. I am so happy our psychiatrist saw the linkage after my son’t medical chart was updated.
Hello Maria,
Thank you so much for your story!! Deplin is the metabolized form of B vitamins and has been found to enable the brain to utilize antidepressants in those who have this genetic anomaly. Please report back to us about his progress. His story may me able to help others. Cynthia
I just wanted to let everybody know my story since it will hopefully save someone else from the suffering i endured. I was so sick and depressed to the point where my blood pressure was sky-rocketed, as an athletic slightly underweight 20 year old. I was having panic attacks and trips to the ER almost daily. Soon my doctors began trying antidepressants and ativan. The ativan worked for about a year, then i was left feeling horrible again. I had two trips to the mental hospital, and each time they just changed my meds, to no avail.
Finally, i saw a psychiatrist who prescribed me Deplin, as she was familiar with the genetic folate disorder and thought there was no harm in trying it on me, as the genetic blood test was very expensive. After a few weeks i began to feel a little bit better, until i was improving slowly each week while taking my other meds including Zoloft and Seroquel XR.
After being out of school and sitting home sick for over 15 months, i am finally back in school finishing my degree. It feels like nothing short of a miracle that i feel halfway back to myself after being so sick and hopeless. I thank God everyday that my doctor was smart enough to prescribe me the Deplin, as it truly did begin to turn things around for me. Even though it took a few months of taking the Deplin to get to where i am now, i knew i was slowly getting better week by week. I now know how sick and deep in a hole i really was. I hope that anybody out there who has been sick like i was for some time, and anti-depressants just haven’t done the trick, to have their doctor prescribe them Deplin and see if it helps you. I’d put my bet on it that after a few weeks you’ll see improvement, and eventually be on your way to getting back to yourself.
Also, i would like to personally thank the scientists/company who discovered/made this medicine, as it truly did save my life. I really owe my life to you. God Bless
Congratulations!!! I am so happy that you found your way to this vitamin that changed your life. We do need to get the word out so that others with a similar history can realize there is hope. Thank you so much for your story – with a happy ending. I will pass it along. Cynthia
I tested normal for B-12 and folate. Is it possible that I have the MTHFR abnormality in spite of normal blood levels? I’ve been taking Zoloft for 3 months and it’s made so subtle a change that I consider it not to be working. I’ve also been taking some samples of Deplin for around a week but haven’t noticed anything different since then.
Hello Barbara,
My assistant and co-leader of the Lyme disease support group has researched the subject extensively and I report to you her thoughts on your question:
” Yes, it is possible to test normal and still have a problem with MTHFR because they are not the same thing. She may have normal levels but that doesn’t mean they are being utilized or “activated”, aka methlated. She should still have a test.
Two possibilities on the Zoloft. One, if she has impaired pathway, it might not be the best SSRI for her. Two, if she has two copies of MTHFR, then she has only small amounts of seritonin that can be utilized and she wouldn’t see a huge difference. The issue with Deplin is iffy. A change can be noticed within a week, but usually only by other people who know the patient. She needs to give it more time. Question, how did she get Deplin? Did someone prescribe that without giving her a test?”
Barbara, please contact me at cynthia_chase@sbcglobal.net for further discussion on this subject. It is complicated and you might benefit from further exploration. Thanks so much for your inquiry, and good luck. Cynthia
i was diagnosed with MTHFR while i was pregnant with my son. it would have gone undiscovered if i hadn’t had 3 previous miscarriages and hadn’t needed to see a prenatal specialist. the dr told me the only issue i would face from having MTHFR was clotting during pregnancy (i had to be induced with my son & almost needed an emergency c-section due to clotting in the placenta), i was never informed of all the other potential issues. it was only recently i discovered the risk of fetal neural tube defects and depression/anxiety…and i had no idea about the lack of motivation, alertness, initiative, concentration, sociability and bad moods until i read your post!! i try so hard to be a happy productive person (which is hard being the stay at home mom of an ADHD toddler) but i can never seem to find the energy to do things or keep the positive mood no matter how hard i try. every one has been telling me im bitchy and lazy for so long that i started believing them…until i read this
finally i have some answers!
i was wondering what your thoughts on taking cymbalta are?
and do you know if MTHFR can effect endometriosis? i asked the only endometriosis specialist in the state and she says she’s not sure (i can never find 1 person with all the answers lol)
anyway, thank you so much for posting this
Elena, I am so glad that you found this post and that you are validated! The main question I have for you: are you on a metabolized B vitamin? Depending on which type of genetic abnormality you have on that particular gene, and if the abnormality is on one or both sides of the family, you may need one or another formula. Once you are treated appropriately with a B vitamin that your body can utilize your body should be able to function more normally, and then when you take the Cymbalta your body will be able to use it more effectively. We will be writing you privately with more information. Thanks for your feedback! Cynthia
this was very helpful! Thank you!
Your description of the MTHFR mutation and what it means to have it are presented in a way that is so easy to digest–thank you! My husband tested positive for this mutation and has been taking Deplin for about 8 weeks with no visible improvements as yet. Do you have anecdotal evidence for how long it could take to see changes? Also,I wonder whether other people taking Deplin have noticed improvement not just in depression symptoms, but in ADHD type symptoms?
Thanks!
Allyson
Hello Allyson,
Thank you for your feedback; it is much appreciated. I have some questions and thoughts for you. What were the specific results of your husband’s test? Homozygous or heterozygous and which mutation/s? The C677T is the one related to depression. Deplin or a good quality Basic B Complex (like from Thorne) is often used in combination with an anti-depressant – most likely an SSRI. The reason for the combination is that the MTHFR is the pathway that produces and utilizes serotonin. By providing the body activated or metabolized B vitamin, the SSRI can then promote utilization of the B vitamins in the brain which build the neurotransmitters which make for normal, non-depressed brain function.
I know of one young lady who showed results in a short time – a few days, but I do not have personal knowledge of a large sample of people.
I am unaware of a connection between the MTHFr and ADD. This doesn’t mean there might not be a connection. On the one side are mental health issues like depression, addictive tendencies, bi-polar disorder, eating disorders that the literature has shown a potential connection with, and on the other, heart issues, bleeding, miscarriage, hypercholesterolemia. The genetic vulnerabilities rest upon which mutation your husband has. Any further questions please feel free to contact me at cynthia_chase@sbcglobal.net. Hope this helps. Thank you! Cynthia